Hate

Racial justice advocates argue the side of the debate that claim Confederate symbols perpetuate “hate” against people of color. They claim these symbols “defend a slaveholding republic,[ ] promote white supremacy, [ ] defy court-ordered integration of public schools, or [ ] promote the agenda of racist advocacy groups.”1 They claim that even if heritage was part of the meaning for heritage defenders “hate was always part of the message.”2  Racial justice advocates believe  “A racial animus is, and always has been, an indivisible part of the meaning of Confederate symbols.”  3

Racial justice advocates also focus on how these symbols impact people of color, referring to them as “environmental microaggressions, subtle forms of racism, that contribute to the ongoing distress and traumatization of African Americans.”4 They state that “African Americans may endure microaggressions in many forms over a day or a lifetime, and the cumulative toll contributes to stress and unwellness that can increase susceptibility to more serious conditions, including post-traumatic stress disorder.”5

Community members argued that the Confederate General names honored a legacy connected to slavery, white supremacy and segregation.  

https://youtube.com/clip/Ugkx5ziCAqGjrCvB2iRiwU88CQGmCHs5-grr?si=ImorGnJE5Jyf-Qeo

https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxOt5vWUnyJkMN3cm2y4quzu_333z9B2nl?si=hmW-Pni6-IRlzx4_

https://youtube.com/clip/Ugkx2rRDg2FT0nQmQYhSn_iJMuaQ48Ki14_G?si=US5edHtUjtgmWZ8P

They raised concerns about the message the Confederate names send to all students, and specifically Black students. These are names of Confederate generals that fought to keep people of color enslaved. Every day these students would be reminded of them when they walked into the building with their names on it. 

https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxGkHGbV6e2ahtzFlpw3Q85-T-CQftl5xz?si=k36Wn6e9T5nWjdSR

https://youtube.com/clip/Ugkxp1FAyVDuWRM8FbeZSg8gKmZpAmTyK6rh?si=nYQ4dqm_AtqohVM

There was concerns raised by some community members that the Confederate names were divisive, regressive, and insensitive. The reputation of the county should be one that is inclusive.  

https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxMjRIrPMo5R-p_6spdmm5Xufm3QRGOtYc

https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxpAS1BK01VUsgaEoxxmDCXNNfe1GO__3g

https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxR6b_IAO6EHC67OsRdDTZ5c2MDp99xuEf?si=BEaMjHyjDssZukGl

  1.  James Michael Martinez and Mary Christine Cagle, “Reexamining Confederate Symbols Displayed on Flags and Monuments in Public Spaces: Two Fallacies in the Heritage versus Hate Debate,” Social Science Quarterly 103, no. 2 (2022) ↩︎
  2. Ibid. ↩︎
  3.  Martinez and Cagle, “Reexamining Confederate Symbols Displayed on Flags and Monuments in Public Spaces: Two Fallacies in the Heritage versus Hate Debate,”  347  ↩︎
  4. Byron D’Andra Orey, Najja Baptist, and Valeria Sinclair‐Chapman, “Racial Identity and Emotional Responses to Confederate Symbols,” Social Science Quarterly 102, no. 4 (2021), 1884.  ↩︎
  5. Orey, Najja Baptist, and Sinclair‐Chapman, “Racial Identity and Emotional Responses to Confederate Symbols,” 1885. ↩︎